How can Bill Belichick fix stagnant Patriots? Maybe he should ask his old pal, Nick Saban

One of Bill Belichick’s closest coaching confidants, and one of the few who can stand close to him in terms of accomplishments, is Alabama’s Nick Saban.

Each hails from a Croatian family that settled in the steel and coal towns of Western Pennsylvania and West Virginia. Both are sons of coaches and are of similar demeanor. Back in the early 1990s, Belichick, now 70, employed Saban, 71, as his defensive coordinator with the Cleveland Browns.

Where Belichick has dominated the NFL (six Super Bowl titles), Saban has done the same at the college level (seven national titles).

So maybe it is Saban who can serve as an example of what Belichick should do as his New England Patriots have a stagnant run — a 2-5 slide kept them out of the playoffs for the second time in three seasons. The Pats will now go four years without a postseason victory.

Tom Curran of NBCSports Boston reported Wednesday that Belichick and Patriots team owner Robert Kraft held a season-ending meeting and walked away in agreement that “changes” are necessary within the organization.

Belichick once ran the most efficient and ruthless winning machine the NFL has ever seen. Since quarterback Tom Brady left for Tampa Bay in 2020, however, New England has drifted. Despite the mediocrity, Belichick has mostly kept everything in house by promoting from within or rehiring former assistants to come back into the fold. Two of his sons are assistant coaches as well.

This past season, New England lacked a named play-caller and appeared to lean mostly on longtime Belichick assistant (and former Detroit Lions head coach) Matt Patricia to coordinate the offense despite a history on the defensive side of the ball. It didn’t turn out well.

The decision of New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick to make Matt Patricia the offensive play-caller was met with a lot of criticism. (Winslow Townson/AP Images for Panini)

At Alabama, Saban never had a slide like his former boss is mired in. However, after winning consecutive national titles in 2011 and 2012, the Tide finished 11-2 in 2013. Saban could have brushed it off as nothing — Alabama was unbeaten until its regular-season finale, after all.

Instead, he saw the game around him changing. College offenses were now wide-open. The old ball control and win-with-defense style Saban had perfected was under a measure of threat. Saban understood the need to modernize.

So he went out and hired the most innovative offensive coordinator he could find: Lane Kiffin, who had just been fired as the head coach of USC. This was a wild move, one that sent college football reeling. Kiffin was known for the kind of brashness and antics that seemed like a bad fit for the conservative Saban. They had no previous relationship. Clashes were predicted (and they did, indeed, come).

Saban didn’t care. He wasn’t looking for a friend. He wasn’t looking for familiarity. First, he brought Kiffin in for a week to analyze Alabama’s offense — from recruiting, to play-calling to practice sessions. Sufficiently convinced, he hired Kiffin to turn the Crimson Tide offense into something as feared as the Crimson Tide defense.

“We are excited to have Lane join our staff,” Saban said at the time. “He is an outstanding and creative offensive coach … and I have always been impressed with what I saw in the games he called.”

The Bama offense didn’t get exponentially better overnight — it was already pretty good, after all. It did improve, though, as the groundwork was put in place. Kiffin was there for only three seasons, but he changed the way talented recruits looked at Alabama’s offense. He was succeeded in the years to come by Josh Gattis and Steve Sarkisian, two other college coaches with no previous ties to Saban and then current OC Bill O’Brien, who arrived from the NFL.

Whereas Alabama won previously with quarterbacks such as Greg McElroy and AJ McCarron – good, but not elite talents – soon they were drawing in Jalen Hurts, Tua Tagovailoa, Mac Jones and Bryce Young. They started throwing to DeVonta Smith, Jerry Jeudy, Calvin Ridley, John Metchie, Henry Ruggs III, Jaylen Waddle and so on.

It may be time for New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick (left) to take a page out of the book of longtime confidant and Alabama coach Nick Saban.  (AP Photo/Butch Dill)

It may be time for New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick (left) to take a page out of the book of longtime confidant and Alabama head coach Nick Saban. (AP Photo/Butch Dill)

The Tide reached the national title game six times from 2015-2021, winning three championships. From 2018-2020, their offense was ranked in the top three in the country in points per game.

Saban’s willingness to see the challenges coming and listen to outside opinions from completely different personalities has helped maintain, if not even improve, his program.

It’s a path Belichick should consider following if these “changes” that he and Kraft are in agreement on include shaking up his coaching staff. Football doesn’t lack innovative coaching minds, especially on offense. And Belichick is still Belichick. The chance to work with a legend of that caliber makes any job in Foxborough appealing.

The question is whether he is willing to identify what he needs and then hire him. Or will he instead stay the course and continue to look inward?

Nothing is guaranteed here, of course. A fresh perspective might fail. But if Belichick wants proof of concept of going far from the coaching tree in an effort to disrupt things via new ideas, voices and perspectives, then following his old friend in Tuscaloosa might be instructive.

Leave a Comment